Pages

Subscribe:

Ads 468x60px

Showing posts with label presuppositional apologetics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label presuppositional apologetics. Show all posts

Saturday, September 24, 2011

Giving a Reason for Our Hope by Grover Gunn


Giving a Reason for Our Hope

by Grover Gunn


In the seventeenth chapter of the Acts of the Apostles, we have an account of the clash of the Titans. The Apostle Paul, that educated, intelligent and erudite defender of the Christian faith, visited Athens, the philosophical center of the pagan world. There at the Areopagus, also known as Mar's Hill, the apostle Paul boldly defended the Christian faith. He proclaimed the Christian message in that ancient citadel of worldly philosophy, that intellectual stronghold of the enemy. Paul there did battle with the philosophical Goliaths of his day. Mt. Zion confronted the pagan Mar's Hill. The heavenly Jerusalem did battle with worldly Athens.

But Paul is not the only apologetic warrior we read about in the book of Acts. We also read about Peter, the man not trained at the feet of Gamaliel but trained to be a fisherman. Acts 4:13 says,

"Now when [the members of the Sanhedrin] saw the boldness of Peter and John, and perceived that they were uneducated and untrained men, they marveled. And they realized that they had been with Jesus."

I find great hope is this verse. Peter was no Paul, certainly not in terms of education, perhaps not in terms of native intelligence and mental ability. Peter even mentions that certain things in Paul's writings are "hard to understand" (2 Peter 3:16). God, however, used Peter as well as Paul as an apologist. Similarly, you may not be another Cornelius Van Til or another Greg Bahnsen in terms of education and intelligence, but God can use you just as He used Peter. God can use you as an apologist, a defender of the Christian faith.

There is a sense in which every aspect of every Christian's life is part of the Christian apologetic. There is something similar in regard to evangelism. Not every Christian is a gifted evangelist. God has not called every Christian to dedicate all his energies to evangelistic preaching or to efforts such as tract ministries. Not every Christian is an evangelist in the narrow sense of the word, but every Christian is an evangelist in a broader sense of the word. The life of every Christian should be a living epistle proclaiming the good news that Jesus delivers His people out of the bondage of sinful living and into the freedom and meaning of righteous living. In that sense, all of life is evangelistic. Similarly, we are not all called to be apologists for the faith in the narrow sense, but in the broader sense of the word, all of life is a defense of the faith. The life we live either adds credibility to our message, or it takes away from it.

Let's now look at what Peter, through the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, said about the apologetic task. Our Scripture reading is 1 Peter 3:15, perhaps the most basic verse on apologetics to be found in the Bible. Some call it the Magna Charta of apologetics.

"But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts, and always be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you, with meekness and fear."

Apologetics is the science of giving a reasoned defense of the Christian faith, and that is what this verse commands us to do. We are to give a defense, and the Greek word translated defense is apologia, the word from which we get the English word apology. And in this context, an apology is not an expression of sorrow for something wrong one has done nor a request for forgiveness. Apology in this context is a rational defense of the faith.

Apologetics, the defense of the faith, is the responsibility of every Christian. It is the responsibility not only of people such as Paul of Tarsus, the brilliant student of Gamaliel, but also of people such as Peter, the fisherman who was categorized by his opponents as uneducated and untrained. Peter says to all Christians, "be ready to defend the faith." Notice some of those to whom Peter is writing: to babes in Christ, to wives, to younger people, to slaves, and to the lower classes who have no social protection against persecution. To all of these, Peter says, "be ready to defend the faith."

I am reminded of what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 1:26-29 about the social status of many Christians:

26 For you see your calling, brethren, that not many wise according to the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called.
27 But God has chosen the foolish things of the world to put to shame the wise, and God has chosen the weak things of the world to put to shame the things which are mighty;
28 and the base things of the world and the things which are despised God has chosen, and the things which are not, to bring to nothing the things that are,
29 that no flesh should glory in His presence.

These are the people called to be apologists for the faith. Apologetics is not a task assigned only to well educated scholars, only to well read philosophers, only to trained logicians, only to skilled debaters. It is assigned to all Christians regardless of their gifts and training.

We too easily think of apologetics as if it were strictly an intellectual enterprise such as a game of chess. We line up our evidences for the faith like so many chessmen on a game board. Then we try to move them with such skill and strategy that our opponent is forced into a corner where he has to concede intellectual defeat. When we start thinking about apologetics that way, we want to leave it to the experts, those masters of strategy who are skilled in debate and well read in philosophy. Either that, or we engage in apologetics ourselves and are tempted with pride because we view ourselves as one of the gifted few. We can become more concerned about winning a debate than about winning a soul. We can become more concerned about demonstrating our knowledge and intellectual sophistication than about defending the gospel message.

Peter is not calling us all to become rhetorical gladiators, people skilled in debating strategy, erudite in the fine points of philosophy, adept in the forceful use of logic. What then does it mean to be an apologist for the Christian faith? The answer is found in 1 Peter 3:15. This passage gives us insight into the apologetic method, which is usually our focus in apologetics. 1 Peter 3:15 also, however, tells us about the apologetic moment and the apologetic manner. I want to look first at these two more neglected aspects of apologetics.

THE APOLOGETIC MOMENT

First, let's consider the apologetic moment. What does it matter if one has honed his apologetic skills to a fine art if he never has an opportunity to use them? Before one can defend the faith, he must first earn a hearing for the faith. I believe the foremost duty of the Christian apologist is to live his daily life in obedience to Jesus in the power of Jesus. That is what, more than anything else, will earn a hearing. It will draw the interest and attention, the amazement and wonder of a watching world. Beloved, we don't earn a hearing for the gospel by parading our intellectual achievements and capabilities.

This passage describes the apologetic moment. It is when someone approaches the Christian and asks him to give a reason for his hope. 1 Peter is written to Christians in a time of persecution, and it gives guidance on how the Christian is to conduct himself during such times of tribulation. It is this supernaturally empowered conduct that causes the world to approach the Christian and to say,

"Give me a reason for the hope that is in you. Your life has caught my attention, and I want to know."

Even when the words "Give me a reason," are uttered as a hostile challenge and are intended as verbal persecution, these words have been inspired by the observation of a life style that is strikingly different.

Beloved, if we are not living in the power of Christ, then we can have the most intellectually sophisticated arguments for Christianity which the world has ever heard, and the world could not care less. Apart from a Christ honoring and Christ empowered life, our intellectual arguments for Christianity will be like those scholarly articles buried in academic journals which no one reads. The Christ honoring life is the cutting edge of apologetics. The Christ empowered life is the foot in the door. It is the necessary price we must pay if we are to earn a hearing.

It is only logical that it would be easier to sell ice skates in Canada than it would be to sell them in Mexico. Similarly, the gospel message is more persuasive where the church is strong than where it is weak, where Christians are living out the gospel message than where the they are living as hypocrites.1 By keeping covenant, by obeying God's law, by loving God with all our being and our neighbor as ourselves, by doing this without complaint, even with a joyful spirit, in the daily grind of the circumstances where God has placed us, we are living out a powerful apologetic, a powerful testimony to the truth of the gospel.

It is when we experience difficulties in life that we are given special opportunities to bear witness with our lives. It is when we are experiencing life's difficulties that others sense that they have more of a window into our souls. We should recognize that our difficulties are not accidents. There are no accidents, only divine assignments because God plans everything that comes into our lives. When we experience material loss, physical sickness or social persecution, we should view it as a providentially given opportunity to bear witness by bearing the fruit of the Spirit.

J.I. Packer described the fruit of the Spirit this way: "Each is a habit of reaction that is most strikingly seen in situations where, humanly speaking, a different reaction would have been expected."2 There is a moment of decision between the stimulus and the reaction, and in that instant, that twinkling of the eye, one's heart character takes over and dictates the response. That response reveals one's inner character to others. Here is where ethics and apologetics overlap. One is in a painful, unfair, tense situation. How will one respond? With love or with bitter hatred? With joy or with self-pity? With peace or with enmity? With patience or with a short fuse? With kindness or with a spirit of revenge? With gentleness or with forceful rage? With self-control or with uncontrollable emotions?

Beloved, even though I speak the apologetic message with the eloquent tongues of angels, without the fruit of the Spirit, I have become a sounding brass or a clanging cymbal. The fruit of the Spirit is a sine qua non of an effective apologetic.

Think a moment about a water saturated sponge sitting on a table. If we push down with our finger even slightly, water runs out onto the table. We immediately know what fills the interior pockets of the sponge. The same is true with people. A watching world can tell what fills the Christian on the inside by observing what comes out when the Christian is under pressure. 3 Respond to life's miseries with the fruit of the Spirit, and the world will say, "Give me a reason for the hope that is in you!" That is the apologetic moment. Respond to life's miseries as the world responds to them, and your apology for your faith will fall on deaf ears.

This key to the apologetic moment is a large part of the message of 1 Peter. Repeatedly this epistle refers to the trials of life and the need to endure them in a matter that brings glory to Christ and which also develops one's Christian character (cf. 1 Peter 1:6-7; 2:12, 19-20; 3:14-18; 4:12-13)

Look again at 1 Peter 3:15. Notice that before one gives a defense, he is to sanctify the Lord in his heart. To sanctify the Lord in one's heart is to set Him apart as someone special, to reverence Him as Lord of all of life, to look to Him as one's hope and stay. Doing that will produce the life that inspires the apologetic moment. It will also enable one to defend the faith with meekness and fear. Setting apart Jesus as Lord not only inspires the apologetic moment but also enables the apologetic manner.

THE APOLOGETIC MANNER

Again, we put so much emphasis on the correct apologetic method that we forget the importance of the apologetic manner. And dare I say it? Our apologetic manner can speak louder than our apologetic method. We can be precise and pure in our method, and yet the harshness and the arrogance of our manner can overpower and drown out our technically correct message. Who can hear the delicate tune of our reasoned message when it is drowned out by the discordant blare of aroused emotions?

Let's say that one man is an evidentialist who argues for the faith with a gentle and loving spirit, and another man is a presuppositionalist who argues for the faith with an arrogant and harsh spirit. Which of these two does the most good? Which of these two does the most harm? I would say that there is no way to know as a general rule. We would have to evaluate each specific case, but the presuppositionalist with the immature manner will in some cases be the one who does the least good and the most harm.

For over five years, my wife worked in the libraries of two different seminaries. She often had to tell seminary students that their library books were overdue and that they owed a fine. She learned rather quickly that being advanced in doctrinal knowledge and precision is no guarantee that a person is emotionally mature.

"And though I understand all mysteries and all knowledge, but have not love, I am nothing."

The apologetic manner is important. What we say is important, but so is how we say it. 1 Peter 3:15 says that we are to give our reasons with meekness and fear. This is the proper apologetic manner.

MEEKNESS

We tend to misunderstand what it means to be meek as the Bible uses that word. J. Upton Dickson founded a group called DOORMATS. That stands for "Dependent Organization Of Really Meek And Timid Souls." Their motto was: "The meek shall inherit the earth -- if that's okay with everybody." Their symbol was the yellow traffic light, whose message is, Slow down and prepare to yield the right of way to others. 4

That's not what the Bible is talking about when it speaks of meekness. The biblical concept of meekness does not imply softness or weakness. It does not mean wimpy. We know this because of whom the Bible sets before us as the premiere examples of meekness. The Old Testament model of meekness is Moses (Numbers 12:3), and the New Testament example is Jesus (Matthew 11:29). Whatever Biblical meekness is, it is not being a doormat. All we have to do to know this is to think of Moses confronting Pharaoh or to think of Jesus with a scourge of cords driving the moneychangers out of the temple.

The root of Biblical meekness is a total dedication to doing the will of God, out of which grows both gentleness and strength. We see meekness in the life of Moses. Though Moses was raised as a prince in Egypt, he chose to identify with God's people in spite of their low position as persecuted slaves. In submission to God's will for his life, he left his luxurious station in Egypt and endured forty years of obscurity as a shepherd in the wilderness. After his encounter with Jehovah God at the burning bush, Moses obediently returned to Egypt to confront Pharaoh, the most powerful man on earth, not with military might but in the power of the living God. When the redeemed masses of Israel lacked faith to enter the Promised Land, Moses continued as their leader and wandered with them in the wilderness. Moses finally submitted without complaint to God's judgment upon him that he could see the Promised Land from a distance but not enter it himself. Here we see a selfless submission to the divine will which resulted in a forceful boldness when confronting God's enemies combined with a patient gentleness when shepherding God's people. Moses stands out as an example of meekness under the old covenant.

We see meekness even more clearly in the life of Jesus. Moses left the treasures of Egypt, but God the Son gave up the riches of heaven. "For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though He was rich, yet for your sakes He became poor, that you through His poverty might become rich" (2 Corinthians 8:9). "... [A]lthough He existed in the form of God, did not regard equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied Himself, taking the form of a bond-servant, and being made in the likeness of men. And being found in appearance as a man, He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross" (Philippians 2:5-8, NAS).

Again, the root of meekness is a total dedication and submission to the will of the Father. The climax of Jesus's submission was His willingness to experience the shameful and painful death of the cross in obedience to the will of His Father. At Gethsemane, He prayed "O My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as You will." The writer of Hebrews comments on this prayer, stating that Jesus "offered up prayers and supplications, with vehement cries and tears to Him who was able to save Him from death, and was heard because of His godly fear" (Hebrews 5:7). God the Father answered Jesus' prayer for salvation from the death of the cross but not by enabling Him somehow to escape the ordeal as He had requested. The Father's answer to the prayer of Gethsemane was Jesus' resurrection from the dead on the third day. Jesus humbly submitted to the will of the Father in this matter, selflessly putting aside His personal desire. Jesus "endured the cross, despising the shame," for the joy of victory which was set before Him (Hebrews 12:2). He was like an athlete who endures the agony of competition for the sake of the anticipated joy of victory. Jesus' anticipated joy was the completion of the work of redemption which would result in our salvation and the Father's glory. This is meekness.

This meekness produces a gentle spirit. Isaiah prophesied concerning the Messiah, "A bruised reed He will not break, and smoking flax He will not quench" (Isaiah 42:3). The bruised reed is close to being broken, and the smoking flax is close to being extinguished. These represent the broken and downtrodden masses who are easily overcome by brute force. Yet Jesus in compassion healed their diseases even while their leaders plotted His death (Matthew 12:14-21). The Son of Man exercises His authority not by forcing others to serve Him but by serving others even to the point of giving His life a ransom for many (Mark 10:42-45).

There is a good example of Jesus' gentle patience near the end of His earthly ministry. When Jesus had "steadfastly set His face to go to Jerusalem," a Samaritan village refused to receive Him during His journey. James and John suggested to Jesus, "Lord, do You want us to command fire to come down from heaven and consume them, just as Elijah did?" Jesus responded, "You do not know what manner of spirit you are of. For the Son of Man did not come to destroy men's lives but to save them." They then went to another village (Luke 9:51-56). Here is gentleness rooted in a singleminded dedication to the will of the Father. Here is gentleness rooted in a sense of mission.

This is the sort of meekness which makes the difference between a wild stallion and a trained war horse. Both are strong, but the war horse is dedicated to doing the will of his master. The war horse will selflessly charge into the line of battle at his master's command, and the war horse will calmly ignore any challenge apart from his master's command. Meekness is this gentleness rooted in a devotion to God's cause and a confidence in God's strength.

How will this meekness affect our apologetic manner? It will eliminate any defensiveness, any proud concern about our winning the argument, any protective sensitivity about our reputation. It will give us patience. It will enable us to ignore personal affronts. It will enable us to maintain a quiet dignity. In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus said that the meek will inherit the earth. The meek will also prevail in defending the faith. The meek are those who care the least about obtaining any personal honor and acclaim, and they are also those most likely to win the apologetic victory.

FEAR

The other component in the proper apologetic manner is fear. Fear can refer to a respect of our fellow man as a creature created in the image of God. The Christian's respectful attitude, however, goes beyond the image bearer to the Creator Himself. The fear of God is the beginning of all true wisdom.

I have just finished reading through C.S. Lewis' Narnia series with my family. Here is an interchange from The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe, the first in the series, which illustrates a proper reverence toward God and Christ:

"Is - is he a man?" asked Lucy.

"Aslan a man!" said Mr. Beaver sternly. "Certainly not. I tell you he is the King of the wood and the son of the great Emperor-Beyond-the- Sea. Don't you know who is the King of Beasts? Aslan is a lion - THE Lion, the great Lion."

"Ooh! said Susan, "I'd thought he was a man. Is he - quite safe? I shall feel rather nervous about meeting a lion."

"That you will, dearie, and no mistake," said Mrs. Beaver, "if there's anyone who can appear before Aslan without their knees knocking, they're either braver than most or else just silly."

"Then he isn't safe?" said Lucy.

"Safe?" said Mr. Beaver. "Don't you hear what Mrs. Beaver tells you? Who said anything about safe? 'Course he isn't safe. But he's good. He's the King, I tell you."

"I'm longing to see him," said Peter, "even if I do feel frightened when it comes to the point." 5

And here is a quotation from another book in the series, Prince Caspian:

"Hush!" said the other four, for now Aslan had stopped and turned and stood facing them, looking so majestic that they felt as glad as anyone can who feels afraid, and as afraid as anyone can who feels glad. 6

A fear of God will have two effects upon the apologist. First, when he defends the faith, he will treat the issue with a respectful seriousness. He will remember that the apologetic contest is not an intellectual game. It is a very serious matter. It is spiritual warfare. The eternal destinies of people are at stake.

Secondly, the fear of God imparts a gentle boldness. Men with a vision of God can speak with confidence before emperors. They are not overwhelmed by outward trappings of power or by diplomas and titles and respect or even by threats to their own safety or prosperity.

I am reminded of the bold fearlessness of Elijah at Mt. Carmel when he mocked the priests of Baal. Baal was the storm god, and his statues often modeled him with a thunderbolt in his hand. Yet this god Baal was not able to light a fire on an altar. As Baal's priests cried out to him to light the fire, we read in 1 Kings 18:27 that Elijah mocked them,

"Cry aloud, for he is a god; either he is meditating, or he is busy, or he is on a journey, or perhaps he is sleeping and must be awakened."

According to the notes in the New Geneva Study Bible, the word busy here is probably a euphemism for a trip to what the British call the necessary room. There is a place for bold fearlessness in apologetics.

I am also reminded of the martyrdom of Polycarp as recorded by Eusebius. In the arena at Smyrna, the Roman proconsul tried to persuade Polycarp to deny Christ and to swear by the genius of Caesar. There Polycarp gave his famous reply:

"You threaten with fire that burns for a time, and is quickly quenched, for you do not know the fire which awaits the wicked in the judgment to come and in everlasting punishment. But why are you waiting? Come, do what you will."7

The beast can order as many as will not worship his image to be killed, but the angel of God cries out, "If anyone worships the beast, he himself shall also drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out full strength into the cup of His indignation." (Revelation 13:15; 14:9-10).

The man who fears God fears no man. The man who sees a vision of the Lord upon His throne in all His splendor cries out, Here I am! Lord, send me! 2 Corinthians 5:11 says, "Since, then, we know what it is to fear the Lord, we try to persuade men" (NIV).

Does apologetics sometimes degenerate into an argument, into an intellectual contest, into a matter of pride and a question of who's right? That will not happen if we have the correct apologetic manner. In Revelation 5, we read that the apostle John heard the words "Behold, the Lion." John looked and saw "a Lamb as though it had been slain." The Christian apologist is to have the humble gentleness and the servant's heart of the sacrificial lamb, and yet the Christian apologist is also to have the bold fearlessness of a lion. We certainly see both in the life and ministry of our Lord. We are to follow His example by giving our reasoned defense with meekness and fear.

THE APOLOGETIC METHOD

The correct apologetic method is what we normally think about when we think about apologetics. Yet I have put the apologetic method third after the apologetic moment and the apologetic manner. The Christ-like life is what gets the world's attention so that someone asks for a reason for the Christian's hope. The Christ-like manner as expressed by the words meekness and fear is what keeps the world's attention as the Christian defends the faith. What one says, the apologetic method one uses, is also of great importance. Our discussing the apologetic method last is not meant to downplay its importance.

First, we must think through our apologetic method and message ahead of time so we will be ready to give a defense. The main problem today with the typical effort to defend the faith is a lack of knowledge. Christians today have a shallow understanding of the Bible and its teachings. One can't really defend what one is unfamiliar with. One can't really defend what one doesn't understand. Getting to know the Bible is, of course, a life long process. One has to prepare.

Second, one must be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks for a reason for the hope that is within him. Now what does that mean? Notice the three words, defense, reason, and hope. Defense refers to one's apologetic; reason refers to the rational, logical use of human intelligence; and hope refers to the essence of what one believes, to faith as it looks to the future and sustains one in the present. The key question is this: in one's apologetic defense, what is the relationship between reason and faith? The answer to this question will determine one's apologetic method.

Now consider carefully the wording of 1 Peter 3:15:

"Always be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks you a reason for the hope that is in you."

Notice that the apologetic defense involves both reason and hope, and thus reason and faith because faith is implicit in the concept of hope. Notice secondly that the reasoning is done in the context of hope or faith. The reason explains and confirms the faith which already existed prior to the explanation and confirmation. This use of a reasoned defense in the context of faith, is the basic methodology of presuppositional apologetics. The presuppositionalist uses reason in the defense of the faith without abandoning his hope in the Christ of the Bible in the process.

FIDEISM

Now notice what Peter did not say. To use a play on Paul's words in Philippians 4, Peter did not say:

"Bear witness to the hope of God which, transcending all understanding, guards your hearts and minds through Christ Jesus."

If Peter had said that, he would have been advocating fideism, which is an apologetic with faith divorced from reason. Our apologetic would be reduced to a bold assertion. Our assurance would be based solely on a deep inner encounter with God which does not involve the mind. Our faith would be a leap into the dark which we cannot rationally explain, much less defend.

One tends to associate this sort of apologetic with cults that define true religion as an ecstatic emotional encounter. Such cults sometimes defend this position by arguing for a strong dichotomy between mind and spirit. The mental process is defined as a function of the soul, and we are admonished to be spiritual and to reject all soulish religion. Therefore there is no place for logical reasoning in our apologetic.

One also associates this sort of apologetic with neo-orthodoxy. Karl Barth believed that apologetics is an illegitimate pursuit. Neo-orthodoxy teaches that God is transcendent or wholly other in the sense that He cannot communicate to us in a manner we can comprehend with our minds. Thus the Bible is not the Word of God. The Bible contains the word of God in that when we read the Bible, God can communicate to us through a spiritual encounter deep within our being, a spiritual encounter which does not directly involve the mind. Thus, to use the language of neo-orthodoxy, God is wholly revealed to us in terms of an irrational encounter but He simultaneously remains totally hidden from us in terms of our mental comprehension.

RATIONALISTIC EVIDENTIALISM

Also, to use a play on Paul's words in Ephesians 2, Peter did not say:

"Use the world's reason, which has no hope and is without God, to establish and prove your hope in God and Christ.

If Peter had said that, he would have been advocating rationalistic evidentialism. This viewpoint says to the pagan inquirer,

"I want to reason as you reason so that you will accept my reasoning. I don't want to argue in a circle and beg the question by assuming what I am trying to prove. Therefore, I will set aside for the moment my belief in God, my belief in Christ, my belief in the Bible as a divinely inspired book. I am going to set aside my faith in everything but my faith in my own ability to reason, and then I will use that ability to prove my faith in God, Christ and the Bible."

This viewpoint advocates autonomous human reason as a foundation for faith. This viewpoint makes faith in human reason more foundational than faith in God and His Word. 1 Peter 3:15 begins by saying, "Sanctify the Lord in your hearts." From the very beginning of our apologetic, we must set Jesus apart as the Lord of our thoughts; we certainly must not set Him aside as epistemologically irrelevant in our quest for common ground with the nonbeliever.

CONCLUSION

Presuppositionalism incorporates the strengths of both fideism and evidentialism while avoiding their weaknesses.

Like fideism, presuppositionalism recognizes that God is incomprehensible. One cannot fit God within the confines of the human cranium. We may not be able to fully understand the trinity or creatio ex nihilo or divine sovereignty, but that does not mean that they are not true.

Like evidentialism, presuppositionalism recognizes that God is knowable. God's communion with us is not limited to the emotional. God has revealed truth about Himself that can be intellectually digested and rationally understood.

Like fideism, presuppositionalism recognizes that God's Word is the most ultimate authority. One can't elevate human reasoning as a self-authenticating final authority and then use it to authorize Scripture as a legitimate and genuine authority.

Yet, like evidentialism, presuppositionalism acknowledges a place for human reasoning in apologetics. Human reasoning can confirm and bolster and strengthen our faith in the Bible as life's self-authenticating and final authority. Reason is a mental tool, an intellectual facility which God has given us to use. We can use it profitably in submission to God's Word. The Bible commands us to bring every thought into captivity to the obedience of Christ and to love the Lord God with all our mind.

Like fideism, the presuppositionalist recognizes that the gospel in the power of the Spirit is more powerful than human logic. Spurgeon put it this way:

"Suppose a number of persons were to take it into their heads that they had to defend a lion. There he is in the cage, and here come all the soldiers of the army to fight for him. Well, I should suggest to them that they should kindly step back, open the door, and let the lion out! I believe that would be the best way of defending him. And the best 'apology' for the gospel is to let the gospel out. ... Preach Jesus Christ and him crucified. The Lion of the tribe of Judah will soon drive away all his adversaries."8

Yet, like evidentialism, presuppositionalism recognizes that we have a responsibility to try to persuade people of the truth of Christianity. God has given weak and fragile humans the honor and privilege of bringing His message of grace to the world. "... [W]e have this treasure in earthen vessels, that the excellence of the power may be of God and not of us" (2 Corinthians 4:7). In Acts 10, God sent an angel to visit the Roman centurian Cornelius to instruct him to meet with the apostle Peter, and God gave a divine vision to Peter to prepare him to meet with Cornelius. God chose to use both the angel and the vision, not to communicate the gospel message to Cornelius, but to enable and facilitate Peter's sharing the good news with Cornelius.9 God has chosen to work through human agents in proclaiming the gospel, including their skills of persuasion.

Man was created in God's image, and that image testifies deep within the heart of man that the Gospel is true. Like fideism, presuppositionalism recognizes that that image is not limited to the intellect. There are voices deep within the heart of man which cry out that the message of the Bible is true. The intellect is not the only witness to God's truth which fallen man has to suppress.

Yet, like evidentialism, presuppositionalism recognizes that the image of God within man includes the intellect. Jesus is to be Lord of the mind. Peter says "gird up the loins of your mind" (1 Peter 1:13). Paul says, "bring every thought into captivity to the obedience of Christ" (2 Corinthians 10:4-5). We are to love God with all our heart, all our soul, all our strength, all our mind. Christianity is not a mindless religion.

THE PLATINUM ROD

Allow me to close with an analogy. W.A. Criswell, in his book The Bible for Today's World, wrote,

"Washington, D. C., is the home of The Bureau of Standards. Every weight and every measure that is used in the United States is a copy of the standard that is kept inviolate by the Bureau in Washington. In that Bureau there is a perfect inch, a perfect foot, a perfect yard, a perfect gallon, a perfect pint, a perfect millimeter, a perfect milligram. Every weight and measure that we have finds its standard in that Bureau in Washington, and all are judged by that standard."10

Let's say that in the Bureau of Standards in Washington, D.C., there is a platinum rod that defines the length of the yard. How do we know that that platinum rod is really one yard long? Should we all get out our wooden yardsticks and measure it just to make sure? No, that would be senseless. Doing that would test not the rod but our yardsticks because that platinum rod defines exactly how long a yard is. That rod is the standard by which we measure all our yardsticks, and no yardstick can sit in judgment over it.

The evidentialist is like a person who insists that his wooden yardstick proves that the platinum rod is one yard long. He treats his wooden yardstick as if it were the national standard and the definitive measure.

The fideist is like the person who burns all his wooden yardsticks. He says that the platinum rod is all he needs. Who needs a wooden yardstick?

The presuppositionalist agrees with the fideist that the platinum rod, not a wooden yardstick, is the final and definitive measure of the yard. Yet the presuppositionalist agrees with the evidentialist that wooden yardsticks are important and have their use. After all, the wooden yardsticks are modeled after the platinum rod, and that is why they are reliable measures. Our experience of their reliability in measurement confirms our faith in the platinum rod. That's because the platinum rod was the standard by which all the wooden yardsticks were manufactured.

The presuppositionalist is the one who believes both in the final authority of the platinum rod and in the use of wooden yardsticks. Presuppositionalism incorporates the strengths of both fideism and evidentialism while avoiding their weaknesses.


FOOTNOTES

1William Edgar, Reasons of the Heart (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1996), 60.
2J.I. Packer, Rediscovering Holiness (Ann Arbor, Michigan: Servant Publications, 1992), 240.
3Craig Brian Larson, editor, Illustrations for Preaching & Teaching from Leadership Journal (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1993), 22.
4taken from the INFOsearch illustration collection, P.O. Box 11749, Arlington, TX 76003, 817-468-0074.
5C.S. Lewis, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (New York: MacMillan Publishing Company, 1950), 75-76.
6C.S. Lewis, Prince Caspian (New York: MacMillan Publishing Company, 1951), 148.
7W.H.C. Frend, Martyrdom and Persecution in the Early Church: A Study of a Conflict from the Maccabees to Donatus (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1965), 271.
8Tom Carter, compiler, 2200 Quotations from the Writings of Charles H. Spurgeon (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 1988), 13; see page 256 of volume 42 of Spurgeon's sermons in their original printed form.
9William Edgar, Reasons of the Heart, 39.
10taken from the INFOsearch illustration collection, P.O. Box 11749, Arlington, TX 76003, 817-468-0074.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

A Short Explanation and Defense of Presuppositional Apologetics by Grover Gunn

A Short Explanation and Defense of
Presuppositional Apologetics
by Grover Gunn

This paper is available from Southern Presbyterian Press, the publishing arm of Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary.

Christian apologetics is the science of defending the Christian faith against intellectual accusations and objections whether they come from hostile skeptics or sincere seekers. The classic Scriptural foundation for Christian apologetics is the admonition of the uneducated Galilean fisherman Peter that we must ". . . always be ready to give a defense (Greek: apologia) to everyone who asks you a reason for the hope that is in you, with meekness and fear" (1 Peter 3:15). The New Testament also provides specific examples of the actual execution of the apologetic task. For example, when the learned Paul of Tarsus shared his simple Christian testimony with an angry crowd at Jerusalem, he began with the words, "Men, brethren, and fathers, hear my defense (Greek: apologia) before you now" (Acts 21:1; cf. 26:24). Because of clear Biblical statements such as these, few dispute the fact of the Christian's apologetic duty. What is disputed is the proper method and approach to use in fulfilling this Biblical obligation.

There are two basic apologetic methods common among Reformed theologians: evidentialism and presuppositionalism. These two approaches basically differ in their understanding of the relationship of the apologetic task of defending the faith to the theological and evangelical task of sharing the faith. According to evidentialism, Christian apologetics is a form of pre-evangelism1, an intellectual preparation that precedes the actual gospel presentation. It is a philosophical and empirical task that is logically prior to any theological considerations.

According to evidentialism, the Christian witness to the non-christian inquirer should initially set aside the existence of God2, the claims of Christ3 and the authority of the Bible4. The evidentialist argues that since these are the very points to be proven, simply to assert their validity from the beginning would be to argue in a circle and to beg the question.5 Also, these religious elements could offend or threaten the non-believer and intellectually alienate him before the Christian witness has had an opportunity to gain a hearing. The Christian witness should instead seek out a neutral arena, some non-threatening intellectual environment common to both the believer and the skeptic. And what better common ground than the axiomatic foundations of logic and science: the law of non-contradiction, the law of causality and the reliability of human sense perceptions? The evidentialist's challenge to the skeptic is that if he the skeptic will acknowledge the axiomatic validity of these three principles, then he the evidentialist will demonstrate the probable truthfulness of Christianity. Taking these axioms as common ground, the evidentialist first attempts to prove from logic and nature the philosophical necessity of the existence of a supreme being. That accomplished, he then endeavors to prove from historical considerations the empirical probability of the validity of the miracles in the Bible, especially the resurrection of Christ. The evidentialist then points out to the skeptic that the Bible claims to be the very Word of God. Therefore, argues the evidentialist, because of the philosophical necessity of a supreme being and the historical probability of Biblical miracles, the skeptic should take the Bible's claim seriously and consider its message.

Presuppositionalists disagree with the above described apologetic method. The presuppositional position is that one should not try to isolate the apologetic task from the evangelical witness and the theological context. One should not set aside the authoritative claims of God, Christ and Scripture in a quest for common ground with the skeptic. Nor should one grant the hypothetical possibility of a world independent of God that can successfully function and be successfully understood in terms of the axioms of logic and science. If the Christian apologist begins his argumentation with the assumption that man can successfully use logic and science to analyze and judge reality irrespective of the truth of Christianity, then the apologist has from the beginning abandoned the Christ "in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Colossians 2:3) and who gives epistemological "light to every man who comes into the world" (John 1:9). To say that logic and science are God-neutral common ground is to deny the existence of the sovereign God of Scripture "for [whom] and through [whom] and to [whom] are all things" (Romans 11:36). To say that the impersonal axioms of logic and science are the most basic principles of reality is to deny the Christ who "is before all things, and in [whom] all things consist" (Colossians 1:17). The Christ of Scripture is the Christ apart from whom man can do nothing (John 15:5). To seek to build one's philosophical and scientific house apart from the God of Scripture is to labor in vain (Psalm 127:1). In its quest for common ground with the skeptic, evidentialism makes concessions that compromise the very essence of Biblical Christianity.

Not only does evidentialism concede too much, it seeks to prove too little. The most evidentialism claims to be able to do is to prove the probable truth of Christianity. But if Christianity is only probably true, then Christianity is also possibly false. The presuppositionalist seeks to prove that the non-christian world and life view is thoroughly self-contradictory and therefore totally untenable and that the Christian view of reality is of necessity true. The presuppositionalist is not satisfied with defending the faith in terms of mere probabilities.

But, objects the evidentialist, with these limitations, a rational defense of Christianity simply is not possible. Without presupposing logical and scientific axioms as a basis for objectively proving Christianity, Christian truth becomes an arbitrary assertion and Christian faith becomes an irrational leap. No, counters the presuppositionalist, that is a false dilemma. There is a third way which both respects the ultimacy of divine authority and rationally demonstrates the truth of Christianity. This third way, which avoids the opposite extremes of blind faith and rationalism, looks beyond logical and scientific axioms to life's most ultimate presuppositions.

The apologetic task must be carried out on this most ultimate level because, contrary to evidentialism, regenerate man and non-regenerate man cannot agree upon some common scales upon which to weigh evidence. Contrary to evidentialism, the non-regenerate man's most ultimate measure of reality is not the axioms of logic and science. Totally depraved man has a more basic commitment, and he would accept an irrational and chaotic world where logic and science have no basis in objective reality before he would compromise his true ultimate commitment. After all, is that not the very world accepted by modern man in post-Kantian secular philosophy? Fallen man's most ultimate axiomatic commitment is not to logic and science but to his belief in the lie of Satan.

What is Satan's lie to mankind? We find this lie in the serpent's temptation of Eve in the Garden of Eden. Satan's pseudo-gospel is that man can be as God in the sense of being his own ultimate authority and do so successfully. Since there can be only one truly ultimate authority, the most ultimate authority cannot be both the Word of God and the word of man. Satan challenged man to put "God in the dock," elevating himself over the Word of God as its judge. If the Word of God is true, it is only because man has judged it to be true. And, says Satan, the Word of God cannot be totally true because God has said that man cannot do what is right in man's own eyes and succeed. God has said, In the day man eats of the forbidden fruit, he will die. But, says Satan, sinful man will not die. Man can successfully have ultimate authority and live. Man can successfully be as God. Man can be the measure of all things and the master of his own destiny and his world won't fall apart. That is Satan's big lie. And that is fallen man's most basic philosophical commitment.

Both before and after the fall, man psychologically started with himself as the immediate agent of his own thought and experience. But only after the fall did man presuppositionally start with himself as the ultimate measure of reality. Before the fall, man sought to think God's thoughts after Him and to interpret experience in the light of God's Word. After the fall, man became a "free thinker" and sought to sovereignly give the brute facts of an impersonal universe their original definition. Fallen man's commitment to Satan's lie as his ultimate presupposition is the foundation of fallen man's total life orientation. The result is that fallen man has a radical sin bias that blinds him to truth about God and Christ and Scripture. Natural man walks in the futility of his mind, having his understanding darkened, being alienated from the life of God, because of the ignorance that is in him, because of the hardening of his heart (Ephesians 4:17-18).

The problem is not that natural man in the pagan environment has no witness to God's truth. The whole world is pulsating with the revelation of God (Psalm 19); there is no escaping it. And man, the creature created in God's image, also has an inner witness to God's truth (Romans 2:14-16). The problem is not a lack of revelation but natural man's interpretation of this revelation. Knowledge of the true and living God bombards fallen man, but he "suppresses the truth in unrighteousness" and "exchange(s) the truth of God for the lie" (Romans 1:18,25). Fallen man takes the objective knowledge of general revelation and subjectively filters it through his sin orientation throughout the cognition process. The route from revelation to theology is interpretation, and natural man can only interpret in terms of his radical sin bias. Thus natural man always has a natural theology, but natural man's natural theology is always an idol making theology. Pagan theology is never an abridged version of truth waiting for the Bible to flesh it out. Pagan theology is never a stepping stone to Christianity. Pagan theology is always a comprehensive and antagonistic perversion of God's general revelation. Natural man's natural theology always produces a "god" whose existence does not contradict Satan's lie, and such a "god" by definition cannot be the sovereign Lord God of Scripture. Marduk and Dagon and Molech and Baal and Aristotle's "Unmoved Mover" are all in the same class and category; they are all depraved idols, not partial descriptions of the true and the living God which are true as far as they go.

In spite of general revelation, the pagan world does not know the true and the living God because of the distorting nature of worldly wisdom (1 Corinthians 1:21). Fallen man's intellectual sin bias is so basic and so complete that even when he is exposed to God's truth in plain language through the special revelation of Scripture, he still does not know God's truth in any spiritually significant sense (1 Corinthians 2:14). He knows but he does not know (Isaiah 6:9). The god of this age has blinded his mind (2 Corinthians 4:4). He is like an illiterate man with an open book in his hands (Isaiah 29:12). He sees God's truth spelled out before him but he cannot grasp its meaning, for to rationally comprehend God's truth is to be persuaded by it and to submit to it in faith. To know the formal content of God's special revelation and not to believe is to see without perceiving (cf. Acts 28:24-28).

The way to deal with fallen man is not to cater to his illusions by telling him he has the authority and ability to weigh the truth of God in the scales of autonomous reason. The way to deal with fallen man is to argue against his illusions and to expose Satan's lie for what it is. For man to reject the true and living God and to seek to be as God is to choose death. And not just physical death but multidimensional death and radical death, death that reaches every area of life and penetrates to the very heart of life.

Man through sin has separated himself from God, but God in common grace continues to uphold life for both the just and the unjust. Fallen man continues to live and function not because of his world view but in spite of it. We must seek to show fallen man that his world view contradicts his own life experience. Man values logic, but apart from God, there is no reason why the mental laws of logic should have any true correspondence to objective reality. Man values science, but apart from God, there is no adequate basis for any real order and design in the universe or any assurance that man is really in touch with objective reality through his senses. Man values ethics, but apart from God, morals are merely changing conventions, and today's abomination can become tomorrow's virtue. Man values human personhood, but apart from God, man is but a higher animal or even an advanced machine, and personal existence is a temporary evolutionary fluke in an impersonal universe. Man values purpose and meaning, but apart from God, these have no real basis. If fallen man is right in his world view, then all in the world that is precious dies. The apologist must press home without compromise the point that philosophy and science based not upon Christ but upon the first principles of the world are "empty deceit" (Colossians 1:8) and "foolishness" (1 Corinthians 3:18-19). Even as the skeptic argues against God, he is using logic and language, which exist and have meaning only because of God. As Van Til has said, the skeptic is like the small child who is able to slap his father's face only because his father is holding him up.

Apart from the regenerating grace of God, fallen man will rebel against these arguments. Apart from the regenerating grace of God, he will continue to cling to his lie. He will argue that finite man and pagan gods really are an adequate foundation for a meaningful world. Or he will sink into intellectual skepticism and arrogantly boast of his ability to live in a meaningless world without resorting to the psychological crutch of Christianity. Or, more commonly, he will find some dialectical mix of false faith and proud despair. All the Christian can do is to argue from the Bible that the man who says there is no Jehovah God is truly a fool and that the forbidden fruit will indeed turn to gravel in his mouth. We plead and argue, but only God can cause the blind to see and the deaf to hear.

After seeking to drive the non-christian "below the line of despair" by demonstrating the self-contradictory nature of his world, the Christian then points him to the one solid Rock upon which he can build a valid world and life view. And of course that one solid Rock is Christ. The apologist presents Christ as the Sovereign Savior and Lord and proclaims His Word as ultimate, self-authenticating truth. In the final analysis, we accept the authority of God's Word simply because it is God's Word (Westminster Confession, 1.4). Just as God can swear by no one higher than Himself, there is also no higher authority than God's Word upon which to base our acceptance of God's Word. The importance of this simple principle cannot be overstated. The apologist can argue transcendentally that human logic and science have no adequate foundation apart from the Word of the true and the living God. He cannot make human logic and science his self-authenticating authorities and then use these to prove God. Logic and science derive their authenticity and authority from God, not vice versa.6

What then is the proper place for evidence in the apologetic task? Evidences must be presented in the defining context of the gospel message. We must reject the notion that we can somehow use evidences and logical arguments apart from the gospel context to prepare the skeptic's heart and mind for the gospel message. It is in the context of the preached Word that God works His work of regenerating grace which enables the spiritually blind to see and believe. Evidences, no matter how compelling, do not convince those who have not submitted to God's Word in faith (Luke 16:31). Because of the noetic effects of sin, fallen man must be born from above in order to see the kingdom of God (John 3:3). True intellectual submission to Biblical evidences is not a mental preparation for faith; it is a part of the phenomenon of faith. Biblical evidences confirm and strengthen faith only in the context of faith. Fallen man submits to the "arguments whereby [holy scripture] doth abundantly evidence itself to be the word of God" only in the context of "the inward work of the Holy Spirit, bearing witness by and with the word in our hearts" (Westminster Confession, 1.5).

We must also reject this idea that we can prove Christianity without concurrently defining what Christianity is. We must not seek to separate the that (the bare fact) from the what (the Biblical significance) of apologetic evidences. The Biblical significance is so closely tied to the historical facts of Christianity that to try to separate and isolate these is to destroy them both. The non-christian might accept the probability of the resurrection of Jesus as a bare historical fact isolated from the claims of the Christ of Scripture and the Biblical interpretation of the resurrection event. But who is Jesus apart from the claims of Christ? He is not the Jesus of Scripture. To accept the "bare fact" apart from the Biblical definition is not even historical faith. The demons have historical faith (James 2:19), but they both believe and tremble. The resurrection of Jesus is a reason for trembling only as it is Biblically defined. Apart from the Biblical definition, the resurrection of "Jesus" is merely an entertaining historical curiosity that belongs in "Ripley's Believe It or Not."

In our witnessing, we do present evidence but only in the defining context of the Word. We have the historical evidences of miracles, especially the resurrection of Christ from the dead, and fulfilled prophecy. We have the testimonies of changed lives. We have a basis for science in the God who created an orderly universe of design and gave man both senses that really are in touch with objective reality and rational minds with a logic that really does measure truth in the created realm. We have a basis for purpose, meaning and morality, for the ultimate reality is the personal God of Scripture and not an impersonal universe or impersonal axioms. We accept God as God and we find flowing out of this a world that is the real world, and everyone in their heart of hearts knows it.

Here we find the true common ground between Christian and non-christian. They both live in the real world created by God and covered with His finger prints. They were both created in God's image. They both know in their heart of hearts that the God of Scripture is the true and the living God and that the Bible is His Book. But, as I said in the beginning, the Christian and the non-christian do not agree on this common ground. Only the born again Christian has admitted to himself what all men in their innermost being know to be true. The non-christian remains self-deceived and is blinded by his love for Satan's lie.

With presuppositional apologetics, the uneducated Galilean fisherman or even the child can have a truly effective apologetic, like the apologetic found in the children's song: "Jesus loves me, this I know, for the Bible tells me so." And yet this apologetic is not mindless or arbitrary. It does not throw out evidence but acknowledges that evidence can have its proper significance and impact only in the context of saving faith. It defends the faith without idolatrously elevating human reason above God (rationalism) or abandoning reason altogether (irrationalism).

The rationalistic apologetic is summarized in the statement associated with Thomas Aquinas, "I believe because I understand." The irrational, fideistic apologetic is summarized in the statement associated with Tertullian, "I believe what is absurd." The presuppositional apologetic is summarized in the statement associated with St. Augustine of Hippo, "I believe; therefore, I understand." Contrary to rationalism, human reason is not a religiously neutral or independent realm that is philosophically prior to faith. Contrary to irrationalism, human reason need not be a futile and impossible task that is contrary to true faith. Consistent with presuppositionalism, the realm of true faith encompasses all and is prior to all, including logic and science, and only in the context of faith is a rational and orderly world possible.


FOOTNOTES

1"Though apologetics may not be evangelism, it is a vital part of pre-evangelism." Sproul, Gerstner and Lindsley, Classical Apologetics: A Rational Defense of the Christian Faith and a Critique of Presuppositional Apologetics, p. 21.
2"We must begin with our reason even before we know that there is a God who validates it." Ibid., p. 222.
3"This all shows that sound apologetics cannot begin with the inspired Bible or even with a divine Christ." Ibid., p. 149.
4"From an uninspired Bible we are arguing for miracles, and from miracles we are arguing for an inspired Bible." Ibid., p. 144.

"We have traveled not in a circular path back to where we began but up to Jacob's ladder anchored on earth in a merely human and historical Bible into the heavenlies of a divinely inspired Word of God." Ibid., p. 155.

"We have proven, independently of the inspired Bible, that the Bible is the Word of God . . ." Ibid., p. 178.
5"The problem arises . . . when we make God a question-begging first principle of epistemology." Ibid., p. 89.

Humans can have the subjective experience of knowing without acknowledging God even though all human experience is dependent upon God as the Creator and Sustainer of life. But can man have a valid and viable epistemology (a philosophical explanation of the subjective knowing experience and its relationship to objective reality) without acknowledging the true and living God? The presuppositionalist's answer to this question is no, and the above quotation is an evidentialist criticism of this position.

6A transcendental argument is an argument that something must be true because of the impossibility of the contrary. The book Classical Apologetics argues transcendentally for the axioms of logic and science:
"In a sense, we are proceeding in a kind of transcendental fashion asking the question, 'What are the assumptions necessary for life and knowledge to be possible?' At this point we are not inquiring about ontological prerequisites to life and truth, but epistemological prerequisites." Ibid., p. 71.
"In our search for common assumptions, we isolate three which are held by theists and nontheists alike. There may be far more than three, but these three represent the bare minimum of working non-negotiable assumptions. The three basic assumptions are: 1. The validity of the law of noncontradiction; 2. The validity of the law of causality; 3. The basic reliability of sense perception." Ibid., pp. 71-72.



Saturday, September 10, 2011

Some Thoughts About the Impossibility of the Contrary

Some Thoughts About the Impossibility of the Contrary


By

Introduction

The “Transcendental Argument for God” (TAG) is typically understood as resting upon the “Impossibility of the Contrary.” We may be in a better position apologetically if we think about the Impossibility of the Contrary (IoC) in terms of three aspects of the IoC. These three aspects of the IoC are definition, dogma, and demonstration.

Definition

What is the IoC?

“Impossibility” refers to the impossibility of predication upon the presuppositions of some position. We might also take the impossibility in view to refer to the impossibility of the truth of some position, the impossibility of the rationality of some position, the logical impossibility of some position, and so on.

“Contrary” is an informal reference to the “contradictory.” Contradictory statements cannot both be false at the same time and in the same respect. Hence if a position is false, then its contradictory is true. Or, if a position is true, then its contradictory is false.

When the IoC is defined within the context of the Christian worldview it simply states something to the effect of, “Christianity is true and every other position is false.” Or we might say (even derivatively), “Christianity is rational and every other position is irrational.” And so on and so forth…

Obviously then other worldviews may make claims to their own versions of the IoC. The Christian, however, must always make his apologetic argument along the lines of some form of the IoC. The Christian must do so because Scripture both prescribes and describes this method. Scripture both explicitly and implicitly argues in this manner. To fail to argue using some form of the IoC is to fail to remain consistent with one’s Christian presuppositions and hence to sin. Such failure is indicative of a would-be adoption of the pretended neutrality propagated by many unbelievers and inconsistent Christians alike.

Dogma

Why believe the IoC?

The reason the Christian adheres to the IoC as explained above is because it has been revealed to us. Christianity is true, and it follows, given the categories of thought provided by Scripture itself, that every other position is necessarily false. Hence the Christian believes in the IoC because God has revealed Christianity to us as true. Additionally, the IoC is taught in Scripture. For example, God claims, “I am the first and I am the last; besides me there is no god. Who is like me? Let him proclaim it. Let him declare and set it before me, since I appointed an ancient people. Let them declare what is to come, and what will happen. Fear not, nor be afraid; have I not told you from of old and declared it? And you are my witnesses! Is there a God besides me? There is no Rock; I know not any.” (ESV) God knows everything. If there is another god, then God would know that there is another god. God does not know that there is another god, therefore there is not another god. In this sense then it is logically impossible that another god exists. There is only one true God, and He is the God of Christian Scripture. It follows that positions which posit some other god are false, or in this case, impossible.

Or consider the claim made concerning, “Christ, in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge.” (ESV) If all of the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ, then outside of Christ there are no treasures of wisdom and knowledge. All of the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ. The Christian must affirm this upon the basis of Scripture. Therefore, outside of Christ there are no treasures of wisdom and knowledge. Wisdom and knowledge are impossible on the contradictory position.

Thus Scripture teaches the IoC both implicitly and explicitly and it should be affirmed by believers. We know the IoC because God has revealed it to us in His word.

Demonstration

How do we show the IoC?

The IoC is used in apologetic argumentation through internal critique. The apologist places himself upon the presuppositions of the non-Christian position and attempts to reason consistently with respect to those presuppositions. (Indeed, more consistently than the unbeliever who holds those presuppositions!) The position of the unbeliever is reduced to absurdity or exposed as arbitrary, inconsistent, irrational, and incapable of rendering human experience intelligible in light of its failures with respect to predication. General principles and operative features affirmed by the unbeliever are left unaccounted for within the context of the anti-Christian worldview.

Conclusion

None of what has been stated here is exact, nor is any of it new. We can, however, use this basic outline to begin to think through the various aspects of the IoC in order to clarify and express our position in a sound and persuasive manner. The implications of thinking about the IoC in this way will become apparent when it is applied to various apologetic encounters and popular objections to presuppositional (Covenantal) apologetics in general and TAG in particular.

Friday, September 09, 2011

Presuppositional Procedure

“Presuppositional Procedure” — By Dr. Greg Bahnsen

Here then is how the presuppositional (transcendental) method of defending the faith would proceed once the preliminary discussions and clarifications have taken place with the unbeliever – and the two outlooks now come head to head.[1. It should not be necessary to point out that what follows is a highly compressed and artificially "programmatic" summary of what the procedure aims to be. In actual conversations, the order in which things are discussed, the relevant illustrations, the irrelevant sidebars, the personal quirks and unpredictable "mental associations" will all contribute to a specific dialog which likely differs from other ones and wanders many different directions in pushing toward its ultimate destination.]

The unbeliever says that he knows that miracles are impossible, that a personal almighty God does not exist, that ethical principles are not normative across cultural boundaries, etc. Or the unbeliever says that the believer cannot know that the Bible is God’s word, or that Jehovah exists, or that Christ was His Son, etc. The Christian apologist must seek to uncover what this unbeliever’s personal convictions are regarding metaphysical and (coordinated with it) epistemological matters which are relevant: e.g., what is the nature of things which are real, how does the world operate, where did it come from, what is man’s place in the world, what is man’s nature, are there moral or epistemological norms which are not chosen by the individual, what are the criteria of truth, what are the proper methods of knowing, is certainty possible, etc.?

Once the believer has a fairly good grasp of the general kind of worldview assumed (or explicitly advocated) by the unbeliever, we can suggest that it should be compared to the worldview of the Christian. The Christian can show that the particular objections raised by the unbeliever would, within the Christian outlook, not prove to be legitimate objections or intellectual problems at all. Thus who really “knows” what he is talking about, the Christian or the non-Christian? The cogency of each side’s theory and practice of knowing must be tested within the broader worldviews of which they are a part. The apologist explains how rationality, communication, meaning, science, morality, man’s redemption and renewal are quite understandable, meaningful, coherent, or intelligible within the Biblical worldview – within “the picture” of thinking God’s thoughts after Him. The apologist then engages in an internal critique of the unbeliever’s worldview to show that it is (1) arbitrary, and/or (2) inconsistent with itself, and/or (3) lacking the preconditions for the intelligibility of knowledge (language, logic, science, morality, redemption, etc.). Since that is the case, the unbeliever cannot “know” the things which he urges against Christianity – indeed, could not know anything at all and loses all claim to rationality. The Christian has proven the rationality and necessity of His scripturally based worldview.

The specific questions or philosophical issues with which an apologist chooses to intellectually press the unbeliever, and the particular aspects of experience which he selects for application of these issues, are wide, varied, and not prescribed in advance by the transcendental program of proving Christianity and disproving any version of autonomous unbelief. Take anything about which the unbeliever is committed or concerned – anything which seems uncontroversial and agreed upon by the unbeliever and believer alike – and from that point display that it would be unintelligible, or meaningless, or incoherent if the unbeliever’s worldview, instead of the believer’s, were true. The illustrations are as wide as human experience – from the curing of polio, to the composing of an opera, to the condemnation of police brutality, to the balancing of your checkbook. And the philosophical issues about which Van Til wrote we should broach to prove the unbeliever’s epistemology and discredit the unbeliever’s were extensive and varied. To consider a few, we read about the problem of making sense of (or possibility of):

predication, reason, explanation, interpretation, learning, certainty, universals, possibility, cause, substance, being, or purpose, counting, coherence, unity, or system in experience or in a conception of a “universe,” logic, individuating of facts, unchanging “natures” or laws in a chance universe, uniformity, science, connecting logic and facts or predication to reality, avoiding contradictions, avoiding the irrationalism or scepticism which arise from the tension between knowing discursively and knowing-asystematic, etc.

In short, the transcendental critique of unbelieving worldviews aims to show that, given their presuppositions, there could be no knowledge in any field whatsoever – that it would be impossible to find meaning or intelligibility in anything at all.

Once again it is important to recall that Van Til’s presuppositional apologetic does not argue that unbelievers in fact do not count, reason, learn, communicate, engage in science, explain, seek purpose and order, etc. Because they psychologically know God, they are both concerned for the issues listed above and are to some extent successful in negotiating or applying them to understand the world and their personal experiences. The issue is not what the unbeliever can do intellectually, but whether he can give an account of it (epistemologically) within the worldview he has advocated or espoused. Because all autonomous perspectives take man’s interpretation of the world to be “original” – to be the primary ordering of particulars or “rationalizing” (making systematic sense out of) the brute facts, it puts man at the center of the knowing process – and pays the price for doing so by slipping in subjectivism and skepticism ultimately (when consistent and driven to the logical outcome of his presuppositions). The only alternative – the Christian worldview – places the creative and providential activity of the Triune God “back of” all of man’s experiences and intellectual efforts, thereby solving the fundamental problems of epistemology which leave the unbelieving critic nowhere to stand. Only Christianity can account for or make sense of the intellectual accomplishments of the unbeliever. The critic of the faith has been secretly presupposing the truth of the faith even as he argues against it; his own arguments would be, upon analysis, meaningless unless they were wrong and Christian theism were true.

Van Til encapsulated the essence of the transcendental argument in apologetics and expressed it memorably in the “Credo” which he wrote for his festschrift. In his proposal for a “consistently Christian methodology of apologetics,” Van Til’s suggestion was that “we claim… that Christianity alone is reasonable for men to hold. It is wholly irrational to hold any other position than that of Christianity. Christianity alone does not slay reason on the altar of ‘chance.’” Accordingly, said Van Til, we must reason by presupposition. And the powerful essence of that presuppositional argument is just this: “The only ‘proof’ of the Christian position is that unless its truth is presupposed there is no possibility of ‘proving’ anything at all.” What the Christian sets forth as the Bible’s worldview – as authoritatively revealed by God – is the indispensable foundation for proof itself – for the intelligibility of reason and experience, the ability to make sense of knowing anything whatsoever. At this point, the unbeliever’s choices are either to acknowledge the truth revealed by God’s word (and repent of his sins, including intellectual autonomy) or to reject rationality itself. He had demanded that the Christian “give a reason” for his firm conviction (“hope”) about Christ and His word (cf. ), and the non-Christian must now accept the Christian’s reasoning (involving his concrete worldview) or retreat from the task and normativity of “giving reasons” (for rationality, intelligibility, meaning, logic, science, morality, etc.). In either case, the apologetical encounter has been successful for, and in favor of the truth of, the Christian position.

Sunday, July 24, 2011

An Informal Introduction to Covenantal Apologetics: Part 45 – Redemption.

An Informal Introduction to Covenantal Apologetics: Part 45 – Redemption.

By C.L. Bolt

Non-Christians suppress the truth in unrighteousness, distorting every fact. Unbelievers are both spiritually and intellectually lost, believing themselves to be final authorities with respect to their own intellectual evaluations of the world. Yet in appealing to one’s own authority one appeals to a shifting foundation that certainly does not serve as a norm. Truth itself is relative in this scheme. The standards, purpose, meaning, motivation, etc. for reasoning are completely lost in this assumption of the possibility of thought independent of God. This series has sought to show in some detail how the creaturely mind asserting its independence from God becomes trapped within itself.

One may observe the lack of purpose behind the unbelieving scholar’s work, intelligent men missing obvious points, and people making obvious blunders in reasoning and see these as a result of the noetic effects of sin. Scripture describes in great detail the futility, darkness, ignorance, and hardness of the unbelieving mind, understanding, and heart.

If evidences and facts were clear and the minds and reasoning capabilities of people were everything many want to claim for them then we would expect to find widespread agreement concerning evidences and facts, but we find the opposite. Sometimes people even indulge in their irrationality and take pleasure in error. Reasoning is directly tied to morality and soteriology. There is a desperate human need for salvation not only spiritually but intellectually as well. The person must be viewed as a whole even in discussions of sin and salvation.

Central to the Christian worldview is the Gospel and so central to our apologetic is the thing that every sinner needs; the truth of redemption in Christ Jesus. The Gospel is the preached and received message that Jesus Christ died for our sins, was buried, and was raised again in accordance with the Scriptures. The Gospel of Scripture does not call for changing or adding a few beliefs to one’s worldview, but calls for repentance from sin and faith in Jesus Christ. Conversion includes the entire person and worldview rather than parts of them. In conversion God removes the unbeliever from his sinful, rebellious, allegedly independent presupposition and places him or her onto the Christ-saturated center of the Christian worldview as the ultimate presupposition. The entirety of the Christian worldview must be brought to bear upon the unbeliever through the Word of God. It is only a thoroughly biblical view of the world that makes sense of anything.

The cross of Jesus Christ brings us as believers into a knowledge of God whereby we begin to see God, the world, and ourselves as they truly are. Jesus is our personal Lord and Savior. His work saves us from our corruption and guilt, and this applies even to the intellect which is, again, affected by sin. Were it not for the work of Christ it would not be possible to think as we ought. Apologists have long pointed out the need for redemption in the context of justice. God, if He is just, must punish sin, but apart from a Suffering Servant this means that none of us will go free. The necessity of redemption in this sense has been brought against positions like Islam and Judaism which claim to have a just God and yet have people who get away with their sins. This is an important point, and one which should not be neglected in an apologetic, but the necessity of redemption goes deeper than this.

God did not plan for humanity to find its way to Him on an individual, autonomous basis. God revealed Himself to humanity. There is a necessity to the revelation of God, and it is redemptive in nature. If an apologetic method is to be consistent then it must start with the Bible and plead with sinners not upon the basis of their own authority but upon the authority of the Word of God which defines the unregenerate sinner as created by God in His image and for His glory. We as believers walk now as children of light and have been saved from the futility of our minds, lack of understanding, alienation from God, spiritual deadness, ignorance, and hardness of heart. We are in union with and alive in Christ and no longer stumble through the darkness as we once did. Redemption renders it possible to see things truly. We are saved eternally and epistemologically.

The need for the salvation of the whole self, and hence the mind, is to be emphasized in an evangelistic/apologetic encounter. There is neither hope nor remedy for the sinful state and intellectual folly of the unbelieving worldview apart from the Christ of Scripture. Having the problems of the intellect fixed begins with having the problem of sin fixed and there is only one way that happens – conversion to Christ. Faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the Word of Christ.